Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Natalie McGlocklin's avatar

the number of times I've thought to myself "well I have a book" when encountering a situation that might be less than ideal... a book can get us through quite a lot.

Expand full comment
Nicole Jensen's avatar

My book club read Prose’s ‘The Maid’ several months back and overall the group enjoyed it for the light, cozy read that it was. As you mention though, I did have a few head-tilt moments of question regarding the neurodivergent characteristics of the main character. As I recall, my biggest sticking point was the arc of her transformation throughout the book. I found her initial presentation endearing and relatable with her anxious, quiet, detail-oriented, rigid and conversationally awkward traits. As the story progressed however, the character radically altered her persona, in a sense she OVERCAME those perceived weaknesses and emerged at the end as a confident, sometimes confrontational, savvy, quick-thinking and even quicker-acting problem solver. I would have liked to see the character remain true to her initially established traits while amplifying the strength of those traits throughout the story instead of undergoing a complete flip as if those deeply ingrained characteristics were things to be ‘fixed.’ That being said, we all very much enjoyed the book and I may have been the outlier who was analyzing the psychological ramifications of the character transformation when we met to review.

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts